Oct. 6 – In a 180 degree reversal from last month when China found itself calling on Japan to return a detained fishing captain, Vietnam on Wednesday demanded that China release nine fishermen arrested in the South China Sea near the disputed Paracel Island group.
The Vietnamese fishermen were arrested Sept. 11, Vietnam’s Foreign Ministry announced. China is demanding that the boat owner pay a fine for fishing with explosives before the crew will be released, the ministry said.
The Vietnamese government contends that there were no explosives aboard the boat and that the fishermen were only using lamps and nets to fish.
“The arrest and settlement are irrational,” an unnamed Foreign Ministry official told Vietnamese state media.
Discussions have been held in Hanoi and Beijing, but China has refused to release the fishermen and their boat until the fine is paid, the ministry said. Vietnam maintains that no laws were broken and the boat was operating in its own waters.
The row comes a week before regional defense ministers are scheduled to meet in Hanoi at an ASEAN conference.
China has become increasingly assertive in disputed areas where it claims sovereignty. Last month, relations between China and Japan plunged to the lowest level in years after the captain of a Chinese fishing boat was detained near a disputed island group in the East China Sea following a collision between the trawler and a Japanese patrol vessel.











The areas are disputed between China and Vietnam although China has control over the whole Paracel group. If it were me, I would release the fisherman and issue a statement saying that they drifted into disputed waters and that their release is in no way a challange to China’s ownership of that group of islets. That way China could claim moral superiority (compared to Japanese actions a couple of weeks ago), the fishermen return to their families, the Vietnamese government is made to look good to their people, but with the territorial waters dispute back to square one.
Just as I predicted here: http://www.china-briefing.com/news/2010/10/04/china-to-enter-three-year-decline-as-problems-mount.html